{"metric_specification":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.5281\/zenodo.4081213","metric_version":"metrics_v0.4.yaml","request":{"metadata_service_endpoint":"","metadata_service_type":"oai_pmh","normalized_object_identifier":"10.5281\/zenodo.6460190","oaipmh_endpoint":null,"object_identifier":"10.5281\/zenodo.6460190","test_debug":true,"use_datacite":true},"results":[{"id":1,"maturity":3,"metric_identifier":"FsF-F1-01D","metric_name":"Data is assigned a globally unique identifier.","metric_tests":{"FsF-F1-01D-1":{"metric_test_maturity":3,"metric_test_name":"Identifier is resolvable and follows a defined unique identifier syntax (IRI, URL)","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-F1-01D-2":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Identifier is not resolvable but follows an UUID or HASH type syntax","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"}},"output":{"guid":"10.5281\/zenodo.6460190","guid_scheme":"doi"},"score":{"earned":1,"total":1},"test_debug":["INFO: Using idutils schemes","SUCCESS: Unique identifier schemes found ['doi', 'handle']","INFO: Finalized unique identifier scheme - doi"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":2,"maturity":3,"metric_identifier":"FsF-F1-02D","metric_name":"Data is assigned a persistent identifier.","metric_tests":{"FsF-F1-02D-1":{"metric_test_maturity":1,"metric_test_name":"Identifier follows a defined persistent identifier syntax","metric_test_score":0.5,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-F1-02D-2":{"metric_test_maturity":3,"metric_test_name":"Persistent identifier is resolvable","metric_test_score":0.5,"metric_test_status":"pass"}},"output":{"pid":"http:\/\/doi.org\/10.5281\/zenodo.6460190","pid_scheme":"doi","resolvable_status":true,"resolved_url":"https:\/\/zenodo.org\/record\/6460190"},"score":{"earned":1,"total":1},"test_debug":["INFO: PID schemes-based assessment supported by the assessment service - ['ark', 'arxiv', 'bioproject', 'biosample', 'doi', 'ensembl', 'genome', 'gnd', 'handle', 'lsid', 'pmid', 'pmcid', 'purl', 'refseq', 'sra', 'uniprot', 'urn']","INFO: Retrieving page -: http:\/\/doi.org\/10.5281\/zenodo.6460190 as text\/html, application\/xhtml+xml, application\/xml;q=0.5, text\/xml;q=0.5, application\/rdf+xml;q=0.5","INFO: Object identifier active (status code = 200)","SUCCESS: Persistence identifier scheme -: doi"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":3,"maturity":3,"metric_identifier":"FsF-F2-01M","metric_name":"Metadata includes descriptive core elements (creator, title, data identifier, publisher, publication date, summary and keywords) to support data findability.","metric_tests":{"FsF-F2-01M-1":{"metric_test_maturity":1,"metric_test_name":"Metadata has been made available via common web methods","metric_test_score":0.5,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-F2-01M-1a":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Metadata is embedded in the landing page XHTML\/HTML code","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-F2-01M-1b":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Metadata is accessible through content negotiation","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-F2-01M-1c":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Metadata is accessible via typed links","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"},"FsF-F2-01M-1d":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Metadata is accessible via signposting links","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"},"FsF-F2-01M-2":{"metric_test_maturity":2,"metric_test_name":"Core data citation metadata is available","metric_test_score":0.5,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-F2-01M-3":{"metric_test_maturity":3,"metric_test_name":"Core descriptive metadata is available","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"}},"output":{"core_metadata_found":{"creator":["Sergio E Uribe","Ahmad Sofi-Mahmudi","Eero Raittio","Ilze Maldupa","Baiba Vilne"],"keywords":["FAIR","Dentistry","Dental publications","Deep Learning\/Machine Learning","Dental informatics\/bioinformatics","Electronic dental records","Outcomes research"],"object_identifier":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.5281\/zenodo.6460190","object_type":"Dataset","publication_date":"2022-04-14","publisher":"Zenodo","summary":"<p>This dataset contains open access publications in EPMC dental journals from 2016 to 2021 and 500 non-open access dental publications.&nbsp;We evaluated the level of compliance with the FAIR principles. The original dataset and codebook are attached.&nbsp;<\/p>","title":"Dataset Dental research data availability and quality according to FAIR principles"},"core_metadata_source":[["Schema.org JSON-LD (Embedded)","embedded"],["Embedded DublinCore","embedded"],["Embedded Microdata","embedded"],["Embedded OpenGraph","embedded"],["Schema.org JSON-LD (Negotiated)","negotiated"],["Datacite Search","negotiated"]],"core_metadata_status":"all metadata"},"score":{"earned":2,"total":2},"test_debug":["INFO: Trying to identify some EMBEDDED metadata in content retrieved during PID verification process (FsF-F1-02D)","INFO: Content negotiation accept=text\/html, application\/xhtml+xml, application\/xml;q=0.5, text\/xml;q=0.5, application\/rdf+xml;q=0.5, status=200","INFO: Using Cached response content","INFO: Starting to identify EMBEDDED metadata at -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/record\/6460190","INFO: Trying to retrieve schema.org JSON-LD metadata from html page","INFO: Trying to extract schema.org JSON-LD metadata from -: Schema.org JSON-LD (Embedded)","INFO: Found schema.org JSON-LD which seems to be valid, based on the given context type -:Dataset","SUCCESS: Found schema.org JSON-LD metadata in html page -: dict_keys(['title', 'object_type', 'publication_date', 'creator', 'license', 'summary', 'keywords', 'object_identifier', 'object_content_identifier'])","INFO: Trying to retrieve Dublin Core metadata from html page","SUCCESS: Found DublinCore metadata -: dict_keys(['summary'])","INFO: Trying to retrieve Microdata metadata from html page","INFO: Trying to extract Microdata metadata from -: Embedded Microdata","SUCCESS: Found microdata metadata -: dict_keys(['object_type'])","INFO: Trying to retrieve RDFa metadata from html page","INFO: RDFa metadata parsing exception, probably no RDFa embedded in HTML -:'str' object has no attribute 'decode'","INFO: Trying to retrieve OpenGraph metadata from html page","INFO: Found OpenGraph metadata-: dict_keys(['title', 'object_identifier', 'summary', 'publisher'])","INFO: Could not identify OpenGraph metadata","SUCCESS: Found OpenGraph metadata -: dict_keys(['title', 'object_identifier', 'summary', 'publisher'])","INFO: Trying to identify Typed Links to data items in html page","INFO: Starting to identify EXTERNAL metadata through content negotiation or typed links","INFO: Trying to retrieve XML metadata through content negotiation from URL -: http:\/\/doi.org\/10.5281\/zenodo.6460190","INFO: Retrieving page -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/record\/6460190 as application\/xml, text\/xml;q=0.5","INFO: Content negotiation accept=application\/xml, text\/xml;q=0.5, status=200","INFO: Using Cached response content","INFO: Trying to extract\/parse XML metadata from URL -: Generic XML (Negotiated)","INFO: Expected XML but content negotiation responded -: html","INFO: Could not identify metadata properties in XML","INFO: Trying to retrieve schema.org JSON-LD metadata through content negotiation from URL -: http:\/\/doi.org\/10.5281\/zenodo.6460190","INFO: Retrieving page -: http:\/\/doi.org\/10.5281\/zenodo.6460190 as application\/vnd.schemaorg.ld+json, application\/ld+json","INFO: Content negotiation accept=application\/vnd.schemaorg.ld+json, application\/ld+json, status=200","INFO: Using Cached response content","INFO: Trying to extract schema.org JSON-LD metadata from -: Schema.org JSON-LD (Negotiated)","INFO: Found schema.org JSON-LD which seems to be valid, based on the given context type -:Dataset","SUCCESS: Found Schema.org metadata through content negotiation-: dict_keys(['title', 'object_type', 'publication_date', 'creator', 'creator_first', 'creator_last', 'publisher', 'license', 'summary', 'keywords', 'object_identifier', 'related_resources'])","INFO: Trying to retrieve XML metadata through content negotiation from URL -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/record\/6460190","INFO: Retrieving page -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/record\/6460190 as application\/xml, text\/xml;q=0.5","INFO: Content negotiation accept=application\/xml, text\/xml;q=0.5, status=200","INFO: Using Cached response content","INFO: Trying to extract\/parse XML metadata from URL -: Generic XML (Negotiated)","INFO: Expected XML but content negotiation responded -: html","INFO: Could not identify metadata properties in XML","INFO: Trying to retrieve schema.org JSON-LD metadata through content negotiation from URL -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/record\/6460190","INFO: Retrieving page -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/record\/6460190 as application\/vnd.schemaorg.ld+json, application\/ld+json","INFO: Content negotiation accept=application\/vnd.schemaorg.ld+json, application\/ld+json, status=200","INFO: Using Cached response content","INFO: Trying to extract schema.org JSON-LD metadata from -: Schema.org JSON-LD (Negotiated)","INFO: Found JSON-LD schema.org but record is not of type \"Dataset\" based on context -: None","INFO: Schema.org metadata through content negotiation UNAVAILABLE","INFO: Trying to retrieve RDF metadata through content negotiation from URL -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/record\/6460190","INFO: Retrieving page -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/record\/6460190 as text\/turtle, application\/turtle, application\/x-turtle;q=0.8, application\/rdf+xml, text\/n3;q=0.9, text\/rdf+n3;q=0.9,application\/ld+json","INFO: Content negotiation accept=text\/turtle, application\/turtle, application\/x-turtle;q=0.8, application\/rdf+xml, text\/n3;q=0.9, text\/rdf+n3;q=0.9,application\/ld+json, status=200","INFO: Using Cached response content","INFO: Seems to be HTML not RDF, therefore skipped parsing RDF from -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/record\/6460190","INFO: Linked Data metadata UNAVAILABLE","INFO: Trying to retrieve datacite metadata","INFO: Retrieving page -: http:\/\/doi.org\/10.5281\/zenodo.6460190 as application\/vnd.datacite.datacite+json","INFO: Content negotiation accept=application\/vnd.datacite.datacite+json, status=200","INFO: Using Cached response content","SUCCESS: Found Datacite metadata -: dict_keys(['object_identifier', 'object_type', 'creator', 'creator_first', 'creator_last', 'publisher', 'title', 'keywords', 'publication_date', 'license', 'summary', 'related_resources', 'datacite_client', 'access_level'])","INFO: Guessed XML retrieval failed for -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/record\/6460190.xml","INFO: Type of object described by the metadata -: Dataset","INFO: Testing for required core descriptive metadata elements -: ['creator', 'title', 'publisher', 'publication_date', 'summary', 'keywords', 'object_identifier', 'object_type']","SUCCESS: Found required core descriptive metadata elements -: ['creator', 'title', 'publisher', 'publication_date', 'summary', 'keywords', 'object_identifier', 'object_type']"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":4,"maturity":3,"metric_identifier":"FsF-F3-01M","metric_name":"Metadata includes the identifier of the data it describes.","metric_tests":{"FsF-F3-01M-1":{"metric_test_maturity":1,"metric_test_name":"Metadata contains data content related information (file name, size, type)","metric_test_score":0.5,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-F3-01M-2":{"metric_test_maturity":3,"metric_test_name":"Metadata contains a PID or URL which indicates the location of the downloadable data content","metric_test_score":0.5,"metric_test_status":"pass"}},"output":{"object_content_identifier_included":[{"content_identifier_active":true,"content_identifier_included":{"header_content_length":"27423","header_content_type":"application\/octet-stream, application\/octet-stream","type":"zip","url":"https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/Figs.zip"}}]},"score":{"earned":1,"total":1},"test_debug":["INFO: Found data links in Schema.org metadata -: [{'url': 'https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/00-README.txt', 'type': 'txt'}, {'url': 'https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/01-analysis-script-fairness-dental-publications-2016-2021.Rmd', 'type': 'rmd'}, {'url': 'https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/02-data-dental-publications-fairness-2016-2021.csv', 'type': 'csv'}, {'url': 'https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/03-codebook-dental-publications-fairness.csv', 'type': 'csv'}, {'url': 'https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/Figs.zip', 'type': 'zip'}]","SUCCESS: Number of object content identifier found -: 5","INFO: The total number of object (content) specified is above threshold, so use the first -: 5 content identifiers","WARNING: Content type given in metadata differs from content type given in Header response -: (txt) vs. (text\/plain)","WARNING: Content type given in metadata differs from content type given in Header response -: (rmd) vs. (application\/octet-stream, application\/octet-stream)","WARNING: Content type given in metadata differs from content type given in Header response -: (csv) vs. (text\/plain)","WARNING: Content type given in metadata differs from content type given in Header response -: (csv) vs. (text\/plain)","WARNING: Content type given in metadata differs from content type given in Header response -: (zip) vs. (application\/octet-stream, application\/octet-stream)"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":5,"maturity":3,"metric_identifier":"FsF-F4-01M","metric_name":"Metadata is offered in such a way that it can be retrieved programmatically.","metric_tests":{"FsF-F4-01M-1":{"metric_test_maturity":3,"metric_test_name":"Metadata is given in a way major search engines can ingest it for their catalogues (JSON-LD, Dublin Core, RDFa)","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-F4-01M-2":{"metric_test_maturity":2,"metric_test_name":"Metadata is registered in major research data registries (DataCite)","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"}},"output":{"search_mechanisms":[{"mechanism":"structured data","mechanism_info":["Schema.org JSON-LD (Negotiated)","Embedded DublinCore","Schema.org JSON-LD (Embedded)"]},{"mechanism":"metadata registry","mechanism_info":["Datacite Search","DataCite Registry"]}]},"score":{"earned":2,"total":2},"test_debug":["INFO: Supported tests of metadata retrieval\/extraction -: 'Embedded DublinCore', 'Embedded OpenGraph', 'Schema.org JSON-LD (Embedded)', 'Schema.org JSON-LD (Negotiated)', 'Datacite Search', 'Typed Links', 'Signposting Typed Links', 'RDF-based Typed Links', 'Linked Data (RDF)', 'B2FIND Metadata Aggregator', 'Guessed XML Link', 'Generic XML (Negotiated)', 'Embedded RDFa', 'Embedded Microdata', 'OAI-ORE'","INFO: Metadata found through - structured data","INFO: Querying DataCite API for -:10.5281\/zenodo.6460190","INFO: Found identifier in DataCite catalogue -:10.5281\/zenodo.6460190","INFO: Dataset already found in registry therefore skipping Google Dataset Search Cache query","INFO: Dataset already found in registry therefore skipping Mendeley Data query","INFO: Metadata found through - metadata registry"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":6,"maturity":3,"metric_identifier":"FsF-A1-01M","metric_name":"Metadata contains access level and access conditions of the data.","metric_tests":{"FsF-A1-01M-1":{"metric_test_maturity":1,"metric_test_name":"Information about access restrictions or rights can be identified in metadata","metric_test_score":0.5,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-A1-01M-2":{"metric_test_maturity":3,"metric_test_name":"Data access information is machine readable","metric_test_score":0.5,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-A1-01M-3":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Data access information is indicated by (not machine readable) standard terms","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"}},"output":{"access_details":{"access_condition":"info:eu-repo\/semantics\/openAccess"},"access_level":"public"},"score":{"earned":1,"total":1},"test_debug":["INFO: Access information specified -: https:\/\/creativecommons.org\/licenses\/by\/4.0\/legalcode","INFO: Verify URL through SPDX registry -: https:\/\/creativecommons.org\/licenses\/by\/4.0\/legalcode","INFO: Found SPDX license representation -: http:\/\/spdx.org\/licenses\/CC-BY-4.0.json","WARNING: Access condition looks like license, therefore the following is ignored -: https:\/\/creativecommons.org\/licenses\/by\/4.0\/legalcode","INFO: Access information specified -: info:eu-repo\/semantics\/openAccess","INFO: Verify name through SPDX registry -: info:eu-repo\/semantics\/openAccess","INFO: Standardized actionable access level recognized as -:public","INFO: Found access rights information in dedicated metadata element","SUCCESS: Access level to data could successfully be determined -: public"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":10,"maturity":3,"metric_identifier":"FsF-I1-01M","metric_name":"Metadata is represented using a formal knowledge representation language.","metric_tests":{"FsF-I1-01M-1":{"metric_test_maturity":2,"metric_test_name":"Parsable, structured metadata (JSON-LD, RDFa) is embedded in the landing page XHTML\/HTML code","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-I1-01M-2":{"metric_test_maturity":3,"metric_test_name":"Parsable, graph data (RDF, JSON-LD) is accessible through content negotiation, typed links or sparql endpoint","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"}},"output":[{"is_metadata_found":true,"serialization_format":"JSON-LD","source":"structured_data"},{"is_metadata_found":true,"serialization_format":"JSON-LD","source":"content_negotiate"}],"score":{"earned":2,"total":2},"test_debug":["INFO: Check of structured data (RDF serialization) embedded in the data page","INFO: JSON-LD (schema.org) serialization found in the data page - JSON-LD","SUCCESS: Found structured data (RDF serialization) in the data page","INFO: Check if RDF-based typed link included","INFO: NO RDF-based typed link found","INFO: Check if RDF metadata available through content negotiation","INFO: JSON-LD graph retrieved through content negotiation, content type - JSON-LD","SUCCESS: Found RDF content through content negotiation or typed links","WARNING: NO SPARQL endpoint found through re3data based on the object URI provided"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":11,"maturity":1,"metric_identifier":"FsF-I1-02M","metric_name":"Metadata uses semantic resources","metric_tests":{"FsF-I1-02M-1":{"metric_test_maturity":1,"metric_test_name":"Vocabulary namespace URIs can be identified in metadata","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-I1-02M-2":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Namespaces of known semantic resources can be identified in metadata","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"}},"output":[],"score":{"earned":0,"total":1},"test_debug":["INFO: Number of vocabulary namespaces extracted from all RDF-based metadata -: 8","INFO: Default vocabulary namespace(s) excluded -: ['http:\/\/ogp.me\/ns', 'http:\/\/schema.org', 'http:\/\/purl.org\/dc\/elements\/1.1']","INFO: Check the remaining namespace(s) exists in LOD -: []","WARNING: NO vocabulary namespace match is found","WARNING: Vocabulary namespace (s) or URIs specified but no match is found in LOD reference list (examples) -: ['http:\/\/schema.datacite.org\/meta\/kernel-4.1\/metadata.xsd', 'http:\/\/www.openarchives.org\/OAI\/2.0\/oai_dc.xsd', 'http:\/\/datacite.org\/schema', 'http:\/\/www.loc.gov\/standards\/marcxml\/schema\/MARC21slim.xsd', 'http:\/\/schema.datacite.org\/meta\/kernel-3\/metadata.xsd']"],"test_status":"fail"},{"id":12,"maturity":3,"metric_identifier":"FsF-I3-01M","metric_name":"Metadata includes links between the data and its related entities.","metric_tests":{"FsF-I3-01M-1":{"metric_test_maturity":2,"metric_test_name":"Related resources are explicitly mentioned in metadata","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-I3-01M-2":{"metric_test_maturity":3,"metric_test_name":"Related resources are indicated by machine readable links or identifiers","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"}},"output":[{"related_resource":"10.5281\/zenodo.6460189","relation_type":"IsVersionOf"},{"related_resource":"https:\/\/zenodo.org\/communities\/bbce","relation_type":"IsPartOf"}],"score":{"earned":1,"total":1},"test_debug":["INFO: No related resource(s) found in Schema.org metadata","INFO: No related resource(s) found in DublinCore metadata","INFO: 2 related resource(s) extracted from -: Schema.org JSON-LD (Negotiated)","INFO: 2 related resource(s) extracted from -: Datacite Search","INFO: Total number of related resources extracted -: 2","SUCCESS: Number of related resources after QC step -: 2"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":13,"maturity":2,"metric_identifier":"FsF-R1-01MD","metric_name":"Metadata specifies the content of the data.","metric_tests":{"FsF-R1-01MD-1":{"metric_test_maturity":1,"metric_test_name":"Minimal information about available data content is given in metadata","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-R1-01MD-1a":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Resource type (e.g. dataset) is given in metadata","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-R1-01MD-1b":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Information about data content (e.g. links) is given in metadata","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-R1-01MD-2":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Verifiable data descriptors (file info, measured variables or observation types) are specified in metadata","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"},"FsF-R1-01MD-2a":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"File size and type information are specified in metadata","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"},"FsF-R1-01MD-2b":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Measured variables or observation types are specified in metadata","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"},"FsF-R1-01MD-3":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Data content matches file type and size specified in metadata","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"},"FsF-R1-01MD-4":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Data content matches measured variables or observation types specified in metadata","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"}},"output":{"data_content_descriptor":[{"descriptor":"file type","descriptor_value":"zip","matches_content":false}],"object_type":"dataset"},"score":{"earned":1,"total":4},"test_debug":["INFO: Object landing page accessible status -: True","SUCCESS: Resource type specified -: dataset","INFO: Number of data content URI(s) specified -: 5","INFO: Selected content file to be analyzed -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/Figs.zip","INFO: Successfully parsed data object file using TIKA","INFO: File request status code -: 200","INFO: Succesfully parsed data file(s) -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/Figs.zip","WARNING: Could not verify content type from downloaded file -: (expected: zip, found: ['application\/zip', 'application\/pdf'])","WARNING: NO info about file size available in given metadata -:","WARNING: NO measured variables found in metadata, skip 'measured_variable' test.","WARNING: Measured variables given in metadata do not match data object content"],"test_status":"fail"},{"id":14,"maturity":3,"metric_identifier":"FsF-R1.1-01M","metric_name":"Metadata includes license information under which data can be reused.","metric_tests":{"FsF-R1.1-01M-1":{"metric_test_maturity":1,"metric_test_name":"Licence information is given in an appropriate metadata element","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-R1.1-01M-2":{"metric_test_maturity":3,"metric_test_name":"Recognized licence is valid and registered at SPDX","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"}},"output":[{"details_url":"http:\/\/spdx.org\/licenses\/CC-BY-4.0.html","license":"https:\/\/creativecommons.org\/licenses\/by\/4.0\/legalcode","osi_approved":false}],"score":{"earned":2,"total":2},"test_debug":["INFO: License metadata found (schema.org) -: https:\/\/creativecommons.org\/licenses\/by\/4.0\/legalcode","INFO: License metadata found (schema.org) -: ['https:\/\/creativecommons.org\/licenses\/by\/4.0\/legalcode', 'info:eu-repo\/semantics\/openAccess']","INFO: License expressed as access condition (rights), therefore moved from FsF-A1-01M -: https:\/\/creativecommons.org\/licenses\/by\/4.0\/legalcode","SUCCESS: Found licence information in metadata","INFO: Verify URL through SPDX registry -: https:\/\/creativecommons.org\/licenses\/by\/4.0\/legalcode","INFO: Found SPDX license representation -: http:\/\/spdx.org\/licenses\/CC-BY-4.0.json","SUCCESS: Found SPDX license representation (spdx url, osi_approved)"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":15,"maturity":2,"metric_identifier":"FsF-R1.2-01M","metric_name":"Metadata includes provenance information about data creation or generation.","metric_tests":{"FsF-R1.2-01M-1":{"metric_test_maturity":2,"metric_test_name":"Metadata contains elements which hold provenance information and can be mapped to PROV","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-R1.2-01M-2":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Metadata contains provenance information using formal provenance ontologies (PROV-O)","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"}},"output":{"provenance_metadata_included":{"is_available":true,"provenance_metadata":[{"metadata_element":"publication_date","metadata_value":"2022-04-14","prov_o_mapping":"prov:generatedAtTime"},{"metadata_element":"creator","metadata_value":["Sergio E Uribe","Ahmad Sofi-Mahmudi","Eero Raittio","Ilze Maldupa","Baiba Vilne"],"prov_o_mapping":"prov:wasAttributedTo"},{"metadata_element":"publisher","metadata_value":"Zenodo","prov_o_mapping":"prov:wasAttributedTo"}]},"structured_provenance_available":{"is_available":false,"provenance_metadata":[]}},"score":{"earned":1,"total":2},"test_debug":["INFO: Check if provenance information is available in descriptive metadata","INFO: Check if provenance information is available in metadata about related resources","SUCCESS: Found data creation-related provenance information","INFO: Check if provenance specific namespaces are listed in metadata","WARNING: Formal provenance metadata is unavailable"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":16,"maturity":3,"metric_identifier":"FsF-R1.3-01M","metric_name":"Metadata follows a standard recommended by the target research community of the data.","metric_tests":{"FsF-R1.3-01M-1":{"metric_test_maturity":3,"metric_test_name":"Community specific metadata standard is detected using namespaces or schemas found in provided metadata or metadata services outputs","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-R1.3-01M-2":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"Community specific metadata standard is listed in the re3data record of the responsible repository","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"},"FsF-R1.3-01M-3":{"metric_test_maturity":1,"metric_test_name":"Multidisciplinary but community endorsed metadata (RDA Metadata Standards Catalog) standard is listed in the re3data record or detected by namespace","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"pass"}},"output":[{"metadata_standard":"DataCite Metadata Schema","subject_areas":["Multidisciplinary"],"urls":["http:\/\/schema.datacite.org\/meta\/kernel-4.1\/metadata.xsd"]},{"metadata_standard":"DataCite Metadata Schema","subject_areas":["Multidisciplinary"],"urls":["http:\/\/datacite.org\/schema\/"]},{"metadata_standard":"Dublin Core","subject_areas":["Multidisciplinary"],"urls":["http:\/\/purl.org\/dc\/elements\/1.1\/"]},{"metadata_standard":"MARC (Machine-Readable Cataloging)","subject_areas":["Bibliographic standards","Information\/library standards"],"urls":["http:\/\/www.loc.gov\/standards\/marcxml\/schema\/MARC21slim.xsd"]},{"metadata_standard":"DataCite Metadata Schema","subject_areas":["Multidisciplinary"],"urls":["http:\/\/schema.datacite.org\/meta\/kernel-3\/metadata.xsd"]},{"metadata_standard":"DataCite Metadata Schema","subject_areas":["Multidisciplinary"],"urls":["http:\/\/schema.datacite.org"]},{"metadata_standard":"Dublin Core","subject_areas":["Multidisciplinary"],"urls":["http:\/\/dublincore.org\/specifications\/"]}],"score":{"earned":1,"total":1},"test_debug":["INFO: Retrieving API and Standards","INFO: re3data\/datacite client id -: cern.zenodo","INFO: Trying to retrieve metadata info from re3data\/datacite services using client id -: cern.zenodo","INFO: Found match re3data (DOI-based) record","INFO: Found match re3data metadata record -: https:\/\/www.re3data.org\/api\/beta\/repository\/r3d100010468","INFO: Inferring endpoint information through re3data\/datacite services","INFO: Metadata standards listed in re3data record -: ['DataCite Metadata Schema', 'Dublin Core']","INFO: Use OAI-PMH endpoint to retrieve standards used by the repository -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/oai2d","INFO: Retrieving page -: https:\/\/zenodo.org\/oai2d?verb=ListMetadataFormats as application\/xml, text\/xml;q=0.5","INFO: Content negotiation accept=application\/xml, text\/xml;q=0.5, status=200","INFO: Using Cached response content","INFO: Skipped domain-agnostic standard listed in OAI-PMH endpoint -: oai_datacite4","INFO: Skipped domain-agnostic standard listed in OAI-PMH endpoint -: oai_dc","INFO: Skipped domain-agnostic standard listed in OAI-PMH endpoint -: dcat","INFO: Skipped domain-agnostic standard listed in OAI-PMH endpoint -: oai_datacite","INFO: Skipped domain-agnostic standard listed in OAI-PMH endpoint -: datacite","INFO: Skipped domain-agnostic standard listed in OAI-PMH endpoint -: datacite3","INFO: Skipped domain-agnostic standard listed in OAI-PMH endpoint -: datacite4","INFO: Skipped domain-agnostic standard listed in OAI-PMH endpoint -: oai_datacite3","SUCCESS: Found disciplinary standards that are listed in OAI-PMH endpoint -: ['marcxml', 'marc21']","INFO: Namespaces included in the metadata -: ['http:\/\/schema.datacite.org\/meta\/kernel-4.1\/metadata.xsd', 'http:\/\/www.openarchives.org\/OAI\/2.0\/oai_dc.xsd', 'http:\/\/ogp.me\/ns#', 'http:\/\/schema.org\/', 'http:\/\/datacite.org\/schema\/', 'http:\/\/purl.org\/dc\/elements\/1.1\/', 'http:\/\/www.loc.gov\/standards\/marcxml\/schema\/MARC21slim.xsd', 'http:\/\/schema.datacite.org\/meta\/kernel-3\/metadata.xsd']","INFO: Found non-disciplinary standard (but RDA listed) found through namespaces -: DataCite Metadata Schema (http:\/\/schema.datacite.org\/meta\/kernel-4.1\/metadata.xsd)","INFO: Found non-disciplinary standard (but RDA listed) found through namespaces -: DataCite Metadata Schema (http:\/\/datacite.org\/schema\/)","INFO: Found non-disciplinary standard (but RDA listed) found through namespaces -: Dublin Core (http:\/\/purl.org\/dc\/elements\/1.1\/)","SUCCESS: Found disciplinary standard through namespaces -: http:\/\/www.loc.gov\/standards\/marcxml\/schema\/MARC21slim.xsd","INFO: Found non-disciplinary standard (but RDA listed) found through namespaces -: DataCite Metadata Schema (http:\/\/schema.datacite.org\/meta\/kernel-3\/metadata.xsd)","INFO: The following standards found through namespaces are excluded as they are not listed in RDA metadata catalog -: ['http:\/\/www.openarchives.org\/OAI\/2.0\/oai_dc.xsd', 'http:\/\/ogp.me\/ns#', 'http:\/\/schema.org\/']","INFO: Using re3data to detect metadata standard(s)","INFO: Found non-disciplinary standard (but RDA listed) found through re3data -: DataCite Metadata Schema","INFO: Found non-disciplinary standard (but RDA listed) found through re3data -: Dublin Core"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":17,"maturity":2,"metric_identifier":"FsF-R1.3-02D","metric_name":"Data is available in a file format recommended by the target research community.","metric_tests":{"FsF-R1.3-02D-1":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"The format of a data file given in the metadata is listed in the long term file formats, open file formats or scientific file formats controlled list","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-R1.3-02D-1a":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"The format of the data file is an open format","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"},"FsF-R1.3-02D-1b":{"metric_test_maturity":2,"metric_test_name":"The format of the data file is a long term format","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"pass"},"FsF-R1.3-02D-1c":{"metric_test_maturity":null,"metric_test_name":"The format of the data file is a scientific format","metric_test_score":0,"metric_test_status":"fail"}},"output":[{"file_uri":"https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/00-README.txt","is_preferred_format":false,"mime_type":"txt","preference_reason":[],"subject_areas":[]},{"file_uri":"https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/00-README.txt","is_preferred_format":false,"mime_type":"application\/zip","preference_reason":[],"subject_areas":[]},{"file_uri":"https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/00-README.txt","is_preferred_format":true,"mime_type":"application\/pdf","preference_reason":["long term format"],"subject_areas":["General"]},{"file_uri":"https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/01-analysis-script-fairness-dental-publications-2016-2021.Rmd","is_preferred_format":false,"mime_type":"rmd","preference_reason":[],"subject_areas":[]},{"file_uri":"https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/03-codebook-dental-publications-fairness.csv","is_preferred_format":false,"mime_type":"csv","preference_reason":[],"subject_areas":[]},{"file_uri":"https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/Figs.zip","is_preferred_format":false,"mime_type":"zip","preference_reason":[],"subject_areas":[]}],"score":{"earned":1,"total":1},"test_debug":["INFO: Data content identifier provided -: ['https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/00-README.txt', 'https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/01-analysis-script-fairness-dental-publications-2016-2021.Rmd', 'https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/02-data-dental-publications-fairness-2016-2021.csv', 'https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/03-codebook-dental-publications-fairness.csv', 'https:\/\/zenodo.org\/api\/files\/78079f6e-2c8a-400d-b51f-fbd554d73a6e\/Figs.zip']","SUCCESS: Could identify a file format commonly used by the scientific community -:zip"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":8,"maturity":3,"metric_identifier":"FsF-A1-03D","metric_name":"Data is accessible through a standardized communication protocol.","metric_tests":{"FsF-A1-03D-1":{"metric_test_maturity":3,"metric_test_name":"Metadata includes a resolvable link to data based on standardized web communication protocols.","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"}},"output":{"standard_data_protocol":{"https":"Hyper Text Transfer Protocol Secure"}},"score":{"earned":1,"total":1},"test_debug":["SUCCESS: Standard protocol for access to data object found: https"],"test_status":"pass"},{"id":7,"maturity":3,"metric_identifier":"FsF-A1-02M","metric_name":"Metadata is accessible through a standardized communication protocol.","metric_tests":{"FsF-A1-02M-1":{"metric_test_maturity":3,"metric_test_name":"Landing page link is based on standardized web communication protocols.","metric_test_score":1,"metric_test_status":"pass"}},"output":{"standard_metadata_protocol":{"https":"Hyper Text Transfer Protocol Secure"}},"score":{"earned":1,"total":1},"test_debug":["SUCCESS: Standard protocol for access to metadata found -: https"],"test_status":"pass"}],"software_version":"1.4.9b","summary":{"maturity":{"A":3,"A1":3,"F":3,"F1":3,"F2":3,"F3":3,"F4":3,"FAIR":2.5,"I":2,"I1":2,"I3":3,"R":2,"R1":2,"R1.1":3,"R1.2":2,"R1.3":2},"score_earned":{"A":3,"A1":3,"F":7,"F1":2,"F2":2,"F3":1,"F4":2,"FAIR":19,"I":3,"I1":2,"I3":1,"R":6,"R1":1,"R1.1":2,"R1.2":1,"R1.3":2},"score_percent":{"A":100,"A1":100,"F":100,"F1":100,"F2":100,"F3":100,"F4":100,"FAIR":79.17,"I":75,"I1":66.67,"I3":100,"R":60,"R1":25,"R1.1":100,"R1.2":50,"R1.3":100},"score_total":{"A":3,"A1":3,"F":7,"F1":2,"F2":2,"F3":1,"F4":2,"FAIR":24,"I":4,"I1":3,"I3":1,"R":10,"R1":4,"R1.1":2,"R1.2":2,"R1.3":2},"status_passed":{"A":3,"A1":3,"F":5,"F1":2,"F2":1,"F3":1,"F4":1,"FAIR":14,"I":2,"I1":1,"I3":1,"R":4,"R1":0,"R1.1":1,"R1.2":1,"R1.3":2},"status_total":{"A":3,"A1":3,"F":5,"F1":2,"F2":1,"F3":1,"F4":1,"FAIR":16,"I":3,"I1":2,"I3":1,"R":5,"R1":1,"R1.1":1,"R1.2":1,"R1.3":2}},"test_id":"d7e62a4e2b0cb2821841b5ccc01a08af37b2346e","timestamp":"2022-06-07T21:50:58Z","total_metrics":16}